127 – Historian Of The Strange: Robert Damon Schneck and The Bye Bye Man

Mike Huberty • January 17, 2017

The man who brought us the story of The Bye Bye Man , Robert Damon Schneck is a writer with a passion for finding the weirdest stories of American history. As a writer, he’s delivered articles on strange and unusual topics for  Fortean Times  (the paranormal gold standard!) and  Fate  magazine, as well as writing two incredibly well-researched books on the subject.

Robert Damon Schneck The Bye Bye Man
Historian of the Strange, Robert Damon Schneck

When we heard Robert tell the story of  The Bye Bye Man on our way back from the Haunted America conference in Alton, Illinois last summer , we just knew we has to bring him on and for several reasons.

  1. The original story of The Bye Bye Man takes place in Sun Prairie, Wisconsin, which is a suburb of our hometown, Madison.
  2. It’s college kids playing the Ouija Board, which is what we used to do when we attended the University of Wisconsin.
  3. There’s a part that takes place in Wausau, which is one of our favorite towns to perform in and we have lots of friends there.

So, it’s not every day that you get a true-life terrifying story that takes place in your area.  And when we found out they were making a movie of it? Well, that was it. We made the note to contact Robert when the movie was coming out and now that time is here!  The Bye Bye Man   has arrived on theaters, and one of the special treats is that they kept the location of the film in Madison (even if they didn’t actually shoot the movie here!)

A movie poster for the bye bye man

Robert wrote the tale of The Bye Bye Man as just a single chapter in his 2005 book,  The President’s Vampire: Strange-but-True Tales of the United States of America , but it’s become his most famous story. It was told to him at a Devil’s Night party by a friend he met at the Parapsychology Foundation in New York City  and that person was actually one of the three people that the story really happened to.

During the cold Wisconsin winter of 1990, three friends kept themselves occupied by messing around with the Ouija Board. But the board put them in touch with a supernatural killer who rode America’s railways and who could sense you if you only thought of his name. Once you said that name out loud, he bound the train in your direction. And not too long afterwards, the friends experienced some strange things that made them believe  The Bye Bye Man  might be more than just a scary story.

the bye bye man robert damon schneck
Oh no, The Bye Bye Man is so scary, I lost my shirt!

Of course, we make Robert tell the whole story of The Bye Bye Man again in this episode, because that’s half the fun! But if you’re interested in the process of professional writing,  he also gives us the story of how he became a successful paranormal author, what happened that turned a chapter of his book into a wide-release feature film, and some more strange and fascinating facts from our nation’s history.

We heartily recommend following Robert on his Facebook page,  Historian of the Strange   and pick up a copy of his original book, which has been re-released in 2016 with new material as  The Bye Bye Man And Other Strange-But-True Tales.

robert damon schneck the bye bye man gloomsinger
The Bye Bye Man and his hunting beast, Gloomsinger

And, perfect timing, the Page 2 Screen podcast discusses the screenplay for The Bye Bye Man in this week’s episode! We’re curious how the film will compare to Robert’s original telling of the story. Check it out here:   International Screenwriter’s Assocation Page 2 Screen

One of the best parts of  The Bye Bye Man ‘s story is the killer’s strange accomplice, who acts as something of a hunting dog for The Bye Bye Man. You’ll have to hear the whole story to really appreciate it, but we just couldn’t resist writing a creepy soundtrack for the Bye Bye Man’s little buddy, the terrifyingly named  Gloomsinger .

When the whistling of a thousand tongues draws near
When a name will find you once you only hear
On the tracks and impending, never resting, never ending,
the whistling of a thousand tongues draws near

When the vision of a thousand eyes grows nigh,
Seeing you wherever you try to hide,
A friendly voice, knock at the door, a bloody sack, flesh and gore,
When the vision of a thousand eyes grows nigh.

A haunted piece of artwork at the Cannon Club at the Gallery Inn in Old San Juan, Puerto Rico
By Mike Huberty July 15, 2025
Discover the haunted charm of the Cannon Club in Old San Juan, where art, music, and a friendly ghost create one of America’s most unforgettable haunted bars.
Cemetery in Puerto Rico
By Mike Huberty July 13, 2025
Discover how a lifelong fascination with ghosts led to the creation of American Ghost Walks, one of the fastest-growing haunted tour companies in the U.S. From early paranormal encounters to a pitch on Shark Tank, this is the story of turning spooky passion into a thriving business.
The stage at the haunted Alaskan Hotel and Bar in Juneau
By Mike Huberty July 12, 2025
The Haunted Alaskan Hotel: A Century of Ghostly Encounters in Juneau’s Most Notorious Lodging
The Wendigo
July 11, 2025
Explore the chilling legend of the Wendigo—from Native American folklore to real-life cannibal tales and ghost stories.
Christopher Reeves flying over Earth as Superman
By Mike Huberty July 10, 2025
Explore the tragic legacy of the Superman Curse—from its creators’ heartbreak to the eerie misfortunes of stars like Reeves, Reeve, Kidder, Brando, and Hackman.
ghostly woman sitting in a theater seat
By Allison Jornlin July 9, 2025
Ghosts of actors that never left the stage in these haunted theaters across the Unites States of America.
Haunted Mickey's Tavern was once the Yahara Hotel in the early 1900s
By Mike Huberty July 8, 2025
Mickey's Tavern in Madison, Wisconsin is one of America's Most Haunted Bars.
By Mike Huberty July 8, 2025
How haunted hotels, ghost tours, and spooky storytelling became a multi-billion dollar global business
The Foshay Tower of Minneapolis at night
By Mike Huberty July 6, 2025
Discovering Minneapolis Ghost Stories
By Mike Huberty July 5, 2025
Explore the superstition, scandal, and ghosts that still haunt Comiskey Park’s legacy from the Chicago Black Sox to the curse of opening on a Friday
More Posts